Tag: CDC vaccination dashboard

  • How is the CDC tracking the latest round of COVID-19 vaccines?

    How is the CDC tracking the latest round of COVID-19 vaccines?

    The CDC’s vaccination data pages all stopped updating in May 2023. How is the agency tracking our current round of shots?

    It’s now been a couple of weeks since updated COVID-19 vaccines became available in the U.S. At this point in prior COVID-19 vaccine rollouts, we would know a lot about who had received those vaccines: data would be available by state, for different age groups, and other demographic categories.

    This time, though, the data are missing on a national scale. Following the end of the federal public health emergency in May, the CDC has lost its authority to collect vaccination data from all state and local health agencies that keep immunization records. As a result, the CDC is no longer providing comprehensive vaccination numbers on its COVID-19 dashboards.

    But we still have some information about this year’s vaccination campaign, thanks to continued CDC efforts as well as reporting by other health agencies and research organizations. In fact, last week, the federal Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) told reporters that more than seven million Americans have received updated COVID-19 vaccines so far this fall.

    HHS also said that about 14 million doses have been shipped to vaccination sites, primarily pharmacies. In addition, 710,000 vaccines for children have been ordered through a federal program that provides these shots.

    Vaccine distribution numbers are slightly easier for the CDC and HHS to collect, as they can work directly with vaccine manufacturers. To understand how many people are getting the shots, though, is more challenging—requiring a mix of data from state and local agencies, surveys, and other surveillance mechanisms.

    What changed with the PHE’s end:

    Early in the pandemic, the CDC established data-sharing agreements with the health agencies that keep immunization records. This includes all states, territories, and a few large cities (such as New York City and Philadelphia) that have separate records systems from their states; you can see a full list of records systems here.

    Through those agreements, the CDC collected vaccine administration numbers, standardized the data (as much as possible), and reported them on public dashboards. The CDC wasn’t able to collect as detailed demographic information as many health experts would’ve liked—for example, they never reported vaccinations by race and ethnicity below the national level. But the data were still useful for tracking who got vaccinated across the U.S.

    These data-sharing agreements concluded with the end of the public health emergency (PHE) in May 2023. According to a CDC report published at that time, the CDC was able to extend agreements with some jurisdictions past the PHE’s end. Still, the report’s authors acknowledged that “future data might not be as complete” as during the emergency period. Even if 40 out of 50 states keep reporting, the remaining 10 represent data gaps.

    Notably, the May report also claims that the CDC would continue to provide data on COVID-19 vaccination coverage on the CDC’s COVID-19 dashboard and a separate vaccination dashboard. But neither of those dashboards has been updated with any information from this fall’s vaccine campaign, as of this publication.

    In addition to compiling data from state and local systems, the CDC has other mechanisms for tracking vaccinations. According to CBS News reporter Alexander Tin, CDC officials highlighted a couple during a briefing on October 4:

    • The National Immunization Survey, a phone survey conducted by CDC officials to estimate national vaccination coverage based on a representative sample of Americans. This survey is currently the CDC’s method for tracking flu vaccinations.
    • CDC’s Bridge Access and Vaccines for Children (VFC) programs, both of which buy vaccines to distribute to Americans who may not have health insurance or face other financial barriers to vaccination. The Bridge Access program was specifically set up for COVID-19 vaccines, while the VFC program covers other childhood vaccines.
    • Contact with vaccine manufacturers and distributors, i.e. the pharmaceutical companies that make the vaccines and the pharmacies and healthcare organizations that give them out. These companies share data with the CDC, offering insights into how many vaccines have been distributed to different locations; though the data may not be comprehensive if not all distributors are included (i.e. just big pharmacy chains, not smaller, independent stores).

    Other places to look for vaccination data:

    Outside of the CDC, there are a few other places where you can look for vaccination data. Here are a couple that I’m monitoring:

    • State and local public health agencies: Some agencies that track immunizations have their own dashboards, reporting on vaccinations in a specific state or locality. For example, New York City’s health department tracks COVID-19 vaccinations among city residents, although the agency hasn’t yet published data for this fall’s vaccines. I have a list of state vaccination dashboards here; this doesn’t currently represent data on the fall 2023 vaccines, but I aim to do that update in the coming weeks.
    • Outside surveys, such as KFF’s COVID-19 Vaccine Monitor: Like the CDC’s National Immunization Survey, other health organizations conduct surveys to track vaccinations. The Kaiser Family Foundation’s COVID-19 Vaccine Monitor is one well-known project, which has been doing regular surveys on COVID-19 vaccine uptake since December 2020.
    • Scientific reports answering specific vaccination questions: Public health researchers may use surveys, immunization records, or other data systems to study specific questions about vaccination, such as the impact that vaccination has on lowering a patient’s risk of severe disease. These studies are often published in the CDC’s Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report and other journals.

    If you have other questions about vaccination data—or want to share a data source I didn’t mention here—please reach out: email me or leave a comment below.

  • COVID source shout-out: Cyrus Shahpar

    The Twitter account of White House COVID-19 Data Director Dr. Cyrus Shahpar is, as I’ve said in the CDD before, an excellent source of updates on all things federal pandemic data. Shahpar shares daily updates of new vaccinations in the U.S., usually shortly before the CDC’s tracker updates. He also shares updated variant prevalence estimates, changes and additions to the CDC COVID-19 dashboard, and other data news.

    But this past Wednesday, Shahpar’s account took on a new purpose: tech support for the CDC’s dashboard. 

    Shahpar said he would “look into” an error with the dashboard’s formatting, after journalist Alexander Tin flagged the issue to him. It’s unclear whether Shahpar’s efforts directly led to the dashboard getting fixed, but it was indeed back to its normal appearance by the next morning.

  • COVID source callout: Still no state-by-state data on vaccinations by race/ethnicity

    COVID source callout: Still no state-by-state data on vaccinations by race/ethnicity

    This week, the CDC added a new feature to the vaccination section of its COVID-19 dashboard: you can now look at demographic vaccination trends at the state level, not just nationally and regionally.

    But there’s a catch: the state-by-state demographic trends only include age and sex data. Vaccination trends by race and ethnicity are still only available at the national level; in fact, when you click on “Race/Ethnicity” on the booster shots section of this dashboard, the CDC directs you to “please visit the relevant health department website” for more local data.

    For state-level race and ethnicity data, the CDC directs users to state public health agencies. Screenshot taken on March 20.

    It is now over a year into the U.S.’s vaccine rollout, and the CDC is still failing to publicly share data on vaccinations by state and race/ethnicity. I actually wrote a callout post about this in March 2021, and nothing has changed since then!

    This is a major issue because such data are needed to examine equity in the vaccine rollout. While it’s possible to compile data from the states that report vaccinations by race and ethnicity themselves, major inconsistencies in state reporting practices make these data hard to standardize. Why isn’t the CDC doing this? Or, if the CDC is doing this, why aren’t the data public?

  • Sources and updates, February 6

    • Vaccination data from dialysis facilities: A recent addition to the CDC’s COVID Data Tracker, this dataset reports vaccination coverage among patients and staff working in dedicated dialysis facilities, which offer treatment to patients with chronic kidney diseases—a group at high risk for severe COVID-19. The vaccine coverage rates for dialysis staff are new as of this week. Overall, about 74% of dialysis patients and 79% of staff are fully vaccinated, and smaller percentages are boosted, as of late January.
    • CDC report provides vaccination data by sexual orientation and gender identity: As health equity advocates have pushed for more demographic data describing who’s been vaccinated in the U.S., the focus is often on race and ethnicity data. But it’s also important to track vaccinations among the LGBTQ+ community, as these Americans are at higher risk for severe COVID-19 due to HIV, mental health issues, and other conditions common in this group. This new CDC report provides a snapshot of these important data, sourced from the National Immunization Survey. Notably, the report found that vaccine coverage was higher overall among gay and lesbian adults compared to straight adults—but lower among Black LGBTQ+ people across all identities.
    • Association of child masking with COVID-related childcare closures: A new paper published in JAMA Network Open this week provides additional evidence showing that mask requirements can help keep schools and childcare centers open. The paper found that childcare programs where children were masked were 14% less likely to close over the course of a year than programs without child masking. For more commentary on the paper, see Inside Medicine.

  • Featured sources, January 23

    • CDC dashboard adds booster shots to key pages: This week, the CDC added booster shot status to its COVID-19 dashboard page detailing the rates of lab-confirmed COVID-19 hospitalizations by vaccination status. According to the new chart (at the bottom of this page), in December, hospitalization rates were 49 times higher in unvaccinated adults over age 65 than in fully vaccinated and boosted adults in that age group. The CDC also added booster shot status to its COVID-19 Vaccination Equity page, with a chart showing booster shot rates according to race and ethnicity. Unsurprisingly, white and Asian Americans have the highest booster rates.
    • KFF: How Are Private Insurers Covering At-Home Rapid COVID Tests? A new report from the Kaiser Family Foundation compares rapid at-home test reimbursement policies for 13 major private insurers, as of mid-January 2022. According to the report, six insurers are currently offering direct coverage (meaning users don’t need to pay out of pocket for the tests), while seven offer reimbursement online, by mail, or by fax.
    • QCovid® risk calculator: This tool, commissioned by England’s Chief Medical Officer for use in the U.K. national healthcare system, helps potential COVID-19 patients estimate their risk for severe symptoms. The tool is meant for use by doctors and other medical professionals who are actively evaluating patients, but the website allows anyone to go through the risk questionnaire and see their status. (You just can’t use the results for anything beyond gaining information.)

  • COVID source callout: CDC’s breakthrough case data

    The CDC has not updated its breakthrough case data since September. A full two months ago.

    Earlier in 2021, the agency reported a total count of breakthrough infections, hospitalizations, and deaths—then switched to reporting only those breakthrough cases leading to hospitalization or death in May.

    The page that used to house this data now no longer includes total case counts; instead, the CDC redirects users to a couple of other pages:

    The CDC and FDA expanded booster shot eligibility to all adults in part because of increasing COVID-19 cases across the country.  But without comprehensive breakthrough case data, as I’ve said numerous times, it’s hard to pinpoint exactly how well the vaccines are working—and who’s most at risk of a breakthrough case.

    MedPage Today, which published a detailed article on this topic, received a statement from the CDC claiming that the breakthrough case and death data will be updated “in mid-November, to reflect data through October 2.” This long lag is due to the time it takes for the CDC to link case surveillance records to vaccination records, the agency said.

    Almost a year into the U.S.’s COVID-19 vaccination campaign, you’d really think our national public health system would have a better way of monitoring breakthrough cases by now.

  • Sources and updates, November 14

    • Directory of Local Health Departments: The National Association of County and City Health Officials maintains this database of all local public health departments in the U.S. You can navigate to health department lists for specific states by clicking on the map, or explore a 180-page PDF that includes the name, website link, and contact information (in some cases) for every single department. 
    • Media and Misinformation update from the KFF Vaccine Monitor: The Kaiser Family Foundation typically updates its COVID-19 Vaccine Monitor project with reports once a month. This week, however, the Vaccine Monitor team released an additional report focusing on American adults’ experiences with misinformation. One key finding: about 78% of those surveyed “believe or are unsure about at least one common falsehood” about COVID-19 or the vaccines.
    • More data on vaccination for kids 5-11 is coming: About 900,000 children in the recently-eligible 5 to 11 age group were vaccinated in the first week since the CDC authorized shots for these kids, the White House announced on Wednesday. At the time, this estimate was higher than official numbers on the CDC’s dashboard due to data lags; but the agency is planning to publish more data on this age group by the end next week, according to Bloomberg editor Drew Armstrong.

  • Sources and updates, October 17

    • COVID-19 cases, deaths, hospitalizations by vaccination status: The latest addition to the CDC’s COVID-19 dashboard, this week, is a set of two pages that break out case, death, and hospitalization rates by vaccination status. The page with case and death rates draws on CDC monitoring programs, and may not be entirely representative of data for the entire U.S. The page with hospitalization rates draws on COVID-NET, a network of over 250 hospitals in 14 states.
    • Hospitalization data will shift back to the CDC: Bloomberg reported this week that the Biden administration will bring the HHS Protect system, which tracks hospitalization data, under the auspices of the CDC. Hospitalization data moved from CDC responsibility to HHS responsibility in summer 2020—a move covered extensively by the COVID-19 Data Dispatch. At the time, this change drew criticism, though the HHS Protect system developed into a highly reliable data source. It is unclear how a move back to the CDC may impact hospitalization tracking.
    • Mask Diplomacy in Latin America During the COVID-19 Pandemic: This dataset, compiled by political scientists Diego Telias and Francisco Urdinez, includes over 500 donations of COVID-19 supplies—face masks, respirators, tests, and more. The data underlie a preprint posted online in August 2020 discussing China’s diplomacy in Latin America and the Caribbean. (h/t Data Is Plural.)

  • COVID source callout: Booster shot trends

    COVID source callout: Booster shot trends

    It’s now been almost two months since the CDC approved third vaccine doses for patients with weakened immune systems—and over two weeks since the agency approved third Pfizer doses for patients with increased breakthrough case risk. Since August 13, the CDC’s dashboard says, about 7.3 million Americans have received a third dose.

    As I mentioned in today’s National Numbers post, these booster shots are obfuscating the country’s vaccination trends. Over one million people have been vaccinated every day for the past week, but roughly half of those people were getting their booster shots.

    One might think I am sourcing that daily booster shot number from the CDC dashboard, but no: it comes, as many key COVID-19 data updates do these days, from the Twitter account of White House COVID-19 Data Director Cyrus Shahpar. The CDC has yet to add any booster shot data to its dashboard beyond a total count of doses administered.

    Shahpar’s daily updates. Screenshot taken on October 9.

    Much as I appreciate Shahpar’s daily updates, I would like to see the agency add those daily booster shot counts to its dashboard. And why stop there? The CDC should also provide information on the demographics of those getting booster shots, such as age and race/ethnicity, as well as geographic trends.

    Notably, the New York Times has added a booster shot trendline to its vaccination dashboard; see the chart titled “New reported people vaccinated.” As I noted last week, 15 states have added booster shots to their vaccine dashboards and reports as well, including three states that are reporting demographic breakdowns. The CDC is behind the data reporting curve, as usual.

  • Sources and updates, September 5

    This week, we have a couple of source updates and a couple of additional data news items.

    • Pediatric data from the CDC: In a rather timely update, the CDC has added a pediatric data tab to its COVID Data Tracker dashboard. The new page links to all the data on COVID-19 and kids that the agency has available: including multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children (MIS-C), demographic data for vaccinations and hospitalizations, and COVID-19 outcomes during pregnancy.
    • Additional vaccine doses (also CDC): The CDC recently added an important new field to the vaccination page of its dashboard: people who received an additional vaccine dose. This includes about 1.3 million people as of September 4. The count started on August 13, when the CDC’s vaccine advisory committee endorsed additional shots for immunocompromised Americans—though the CDC’s dashboard doesn’t distinguish between those additional dose recipients who are and are not immunocompromised, according to their “about the data” page.
    • More states pull back on COVID-19 reporting: Here at the CDD, we love to call out states that stop reporting key COVID-19 data points or make that reporting less frequent. A new article from KHN’s Andy Miller speaks to this trend, which has continued in recent weeks despite the Delta surge. The article specifically calls out government websites in Georgia, which stopped updating public data on COVID-19 in prisons and long-term care facilities “just as the dangerous Delta variant was taking hold,” Miller reports.
    • New study provides rigorous evidence that masks work: On Wednesday, authors of a randomized control trial study—the gold standard of scientific research—shared their findings in a preprint. The study investigated mask use by providing different levels of free mask supplies and promotion to different villages in Bangladesh. Villages that received the masks and learned about their use had fewer COVID-19 cases, with the villages that received surgical masks (as opposed to cloth masks) seeing the biggest impact. This study is a pretty big deal, with one commenter calling it “arguably the most important single piece of epidemiological research of the entire pandemic.” For more context, see this Washington Post article.