COVID-19 Data Dispatch

Tag: Anime NYC

  • Omicron updates: More transmissible, immune evading, but still not cause for panic

    Omicron updates: More transmissible, immune evading, but still not cause for panic

    COVID-19 cases are rising rapidly in countries where Omicron is spreading, including South Africa, the U.K., and Denmark. Chart from Our World in Data, retrieved September 12.

    We continue to learn more about this new variant as it spreads rapidly across the world, though much of the data are still preliminary. Here are a few major updates:

    • Omicron is still spreading very quickly in South Africa, as well as in the U.K. and Denmark—two other countries with great genetic surveillance. Preliminary estimates based on data from these countries suggest that the variant’s R-value is between 3 and 4, indicating that the average person infected with Omicron infects three or four others. As Sarah Zhang put it in The Atlantic: “Omicron is spreading in highly immune populations as quickly as the original virus did in populations with no immunity at all.”
    • Early vaccine studies show a drop in antibody levels against Omicron, but that doesn’t necessarily correspond to overall protection. This week, we saw the first results from early studies evaluating how well vaccines work against Omicron. Here’s a summary, drawing from Katherine Wu’s coverage of these studies in The Atlantic: vaccinated people confronted with Omicron appear to produce a lot fewer antibodies that can fight the virus, compared with older variants. Numbers range from a five-fold drop in antibodies to a 41-fold drop. But remember, antibodies are just one part of the immune system—specifically, they’re the part that’s easiest to measure. Vaccinated people also have memory immune cells that provide protection over a long time period, which isn’t captured in antibody studies. We’ll need more time and more data to actually evaluate how vaccines fare against Omicron in the real world, rather than in the lab.
    • The vaccines seem to protect against severe disease and death from Omicron. So far, the data suggest that our existing COVID-19 vaccines still work quite well at protecting people from severe symptoms—even when those severe symptoms are caused by an Omicron case. “When the shots’ protection ebbs, it tends to do so stepwise: first, against infection, then transmission and symptoms, and finally against severe disease,” Wu writes. For vaccinated people to lose protection against severe disease, the virus would have to change much more than Omicron has. At the same time, however, some experts are concerned that non-mRNA vaccines may not fare as well against Omicron as Moderna and Pfizer, conferring a disadvantage to the low- and middle-income countries that have had less access to the mRNA vaccines.
    • Booster shots increase protection against Omicron. While vaccinated people are less protected against infection with Omicron than previous variants, booster shots appear to help close that gap—even though currently-available booster shots are not designed specifically for Omicron. One U.K. study suggests that boosters can increase vaccine effectiveness against infection from 30% to 75%, for people who received the Pfizer vaccines. In other words: Omicron is a good reason to go get your booster shot, if you’re eligible and you live in a place where the shots are available.
    • Experts continue to be skeptical about Omicron being “more mild.” Reports out of South Africa continue to suggest that cases caused by Omicron are more mild than cases caused by Delta, with doctors saying that fewer patients are requiring hospitalization and those hospital stays are shorter than previous outbreaks. But many of the South Africans getting sick with Omicron may have some protection from vaccination or past infection; this means they’re more likely to have mild cases, as biostatistician Natalie Dean explains in an excellent Twitter thread. Plus, even if Omicron is more mild, it appears to be more transmissible—and a smaller share of severe cases out of a larger pool of cases overall can still lead to a pretty big number of people going to the hospital. In addition, we have zero data at this point on how Omicron may impact Long COVID cases, or how well vaccines protect against Long COVID from an Omicron infection.
    • Early U.K. data confirm Omicron’s high contagiousness and its capacity for evading protection from vaccines and prior cases. After the U.K.’s best-in-the-world genetic surveillance agency first identified Omicron in late November, I wrote that the country would likely provide invaluable data on this variant. Less than two weeks later, the U.K. Health Security Agency has released its first Omicron report. The country’s real-world data confirm that Omicron can spread quite fast: for example, “19% of Omicron cases resulted in household outbreaks vs 8.5% of Delta cases,” wrote epidemiologist Meaghan Kall in a summary of the report. The report also “paints a very consistent picture for Omicron being immune evading,” Kall said, though booster shots help a lot.
    • Anime NYC was a likely Omicron superspreader event. More and more reports have emerged of Omicron cases connected to Anime NYC, a convention held in Manhattan in mid-November. The CDC is currently investigating the convention: officials are working with the NYC health department to contact all 53,000 convention attendees for testing and contact tracing. “Data from this investigation will likely provide some of the earliest looks in this country on the transmissibility of the variant,” CDC Director Dr. Rochelle Walensky said at a press briefing on Tuesday.
    • The CDC formally named Omicron a Variant of Concern. On Friday, the CDC officially designated Omicron as a Variant of Concern and added it to the variant tracking page of the agency’s COVID-19 dashboard. As of December 4, Omicron is causing 0.0% of new COVID-19 cases in the U.S., the CDC estimates. The variant has yet to be added to the CDC’s state-by-state data. Given the continued geographic disparities of the U.S.’s genomic surveillance system, however, we may expect that the variant is already spreading in states where it has yet to be formally identified.
    • Omicron can likely compete with Delta, but we need more data to get a better sense of how well. “Omicron is picking up speed in Europe, which has often served as a preview of what was headed the U.S.’s way. It’s an early sign that the already bleak situation here may get worse,” writes Andrew Joseph in a recent STAT News story. U.K. data suggest that Omicron could cause a majority of cases there within two to four weeks, Joseph reports, and the U.S. may not be far behind. Still, more real-world data from countries and regions with clear Omicron outbreaks will give us a better idea of just how worried we need to be about a potential Omicron-fueled surge.

    In summary:

    More variant reporting

  • Omicron updates: What we’ve learned since last week

    Omicron updates: What we’ve learned since last week

    Within days of its first identification, the Omicron variant has been found on every continent except Antarctica. Chart via GISAID, retrieved December 5.

    There is still a lot we don’t know about the Omicron variant, first identified in Botswana and South Africa in late November. For the most part, what I wrote last Sunday remains true: this variant is spreading quickly in South Africa and has a number of mutations—some of which may correspond to increased capacity for transmission or evading prior immunity—but we don’t yet have enough information to determine how it may shape the next phase of the pandemic. 

    Still, we’ve learned a few new things in the last week. Here’s a quick roundup:

    • More than 30 cases have been detected in the U.S., with the earliest detection in states with robust genetic surveillance. The first U.S. case was identified in California, in a San Francisco resident who had recently traveled to South Africa. As I pointed out on Twitter, California is one state that’s sequencing a lot of coronavirus genomes; combine that with San Francisco’s large international airport, and it may be unsurprising that the variant was first picked up there. The second U.S. case was identified in Minnesota; this state, too, has sequenced a lot of cases, with a lab at the University of Minnesota providing sequencing services for other Midwest states.
    • Omicron is spreading rapidly in South Africa. On Friday, South African scientists said that the variant may be spreading “more than twice as quickly as Delta,” according to the New York Times, though it may also be less contagious than Delta. This announcement aligns with modeling by computational biologist Trevor Bedford, who wrote on Saturday that Omicron appears to have a transmission advantage over Delta. “These are still very early estimates and all this will become more clear as we get comparable estimates from different geographies and with different methods,” Bedford wrote. “But ballpark current Rt of Omicron in South Africa of between 3 and 3.5 seems pretty reasonable.” Rt refers to how fast the virus is spreading; for context, Delta’s Rt when it first hit the U.S. was about 1.5.
    • Anime NYC may have been a superspreading event. The Minnesota resident who became the second Omicron case identified in the U.S. had attended Anime NYC, an anime convention held at the Javits Center between November 19 and 21. City and state officials urged other attendants of the convention to get tested; and a number of the Minnesota resident’s friends have tested positive, according to The Washington Post, though sequencing results are not yet available for these cases. Anime NYC attendees had to be vaccinated to attend, but could meet the requirement with just one dose received right before the convention. And photos from the convention show plenty of people disregarding the mask mandate. It’s too early to say, but I would not be surprised if Anime NYC turns out to be a superspreading event for Omicron.
    • A holiday party in Norway is another likely superspreading event. About 120 people attended a Christmas party in Oslo on November 26. As of this Friday, at least 13 attendees have been identified as Omicron cases, while a number of others have tested positive for COVID-19 (and are awaiting sequencing results). “Our working hypothesis is that at least half of the 120 participants were infected with the Omicron variant during the party,” Norwegian Institute of Public Health physician Preben Aavitsland told Reuters. “This makes this, for now, the largest Omicron outbreak outside South Africa.” Notably, this superspreading event occurred even though “all the attendees were fully vaccinated and had tested negative before the event,” Reuters reports.
    • Omicron appears to be more likely to reinfect people who’ve recovered from a previous COVID-19 case than past variants. On Thursday, South African scientists posted a preprint study suggesting that, when compared to the Delta and Beta variants, Omicron is more capable of reinfecting people who’ve previously had COVID-19. The finding comes from an analysis of over 35,000 reinfections among millions of positive COVID-19 tests. “Although there are a lot of uncertainties in the paper, it looks like an earlier infection only offers half as much protection against Omicron as it does against Delta,” writes Gretchen Vogel in Science, paraphrasing Emory University biostatistician Natalie Dean.
    • Omicron might cause less severe illness than other variants, but a lot more data are needed on this topic. On Saturday, the South African Medical Research Council posted a report that aligns with some other early reports about this variant: so far, patients infected with this variant seem to be getting less sick than those infected with previous coronavirus variants. Specifically: a lower share of Omicron patients in South Africa have required intensive care, oxygen support, or ventilators than physicians there have seen in previous COVID-19 waves. But this report, like other anecdotal reports, has been based on a small number of patients, and many of them have been younger—as older South Africans have been prioritized for vaccination. The number of severe Omicron cases may be low now, but may rise sharply in the coming weeks, Financial Times reporter John Burn-Murdoch pointed out in a Twitter thread responding to the report. Also, it’s way too soon to know how many of the so-called mild Omicron cases thus far may turn into Long COVID. So, a lot of experts are skeptical that Omicron is actually more mild—basically, we need more data. 

    I’ll end the post with this excellent thread from Muge Cevik, infectious disease expert at the University of St. Andrews, discussing the many uncertainties surrounding Omicron:

    More variant reporting